Magnus was so delightfully MAGNUS in this one that I have to give it five stars, even though the plot of the story was a bit weak. It was somewhat disappointing to have Shadowhunter characters that we didn't even KNOW, but of course we couldn't have known them, since there hasn't been a series set in 1920s New York. I loved the time period and the idea of Magnus owning a speakeasy, so all in all an entertaining read!